SCP-674
The first thing I'd want to know about SCP-674 is whether I could undo it. You've got the old Nintendo Zapper pointed at a television. You try the thing once because, come on, of course you want to know if it works outside its game. Then you go to watch the next episode of whatever you messed with and your version of the show remembers it. Everyone else could sit there beside you and swear you're watching the same episode they are.
It's a worn NES light gun with nothing especially weird to find inside the casing. It doesn't even need its cord to work. The point is a screen, and the effect belongs to the person using it. Events on the screen respond like something actually happened in the scene. As far as other viewers are concerned, the show goes along the way it always did. The person who used the Zapper keeps seeing the consequences in later episodes. A character can stay gone even if the user never picks up the controller again.
That's my favorite idea in the file, because I can imagine wanting a show to go a different way and regretting getting what I wanted. What I want in that moment is one change. I don't necessarily want to give up every other thing that would've happened afterward. If I got rid of a character I was sick of, I'd probably miss the first time one of the other characters would've had a decent conversation with them. I might not even know I missed it until somebody else brought it up. At that point I'd be asking my friend to tell me what happens in the version of the show I used to watch.
The article also gets a lot out of the screen having its own rules. The way a cartoon reacts can be wildly different from what you'd see in a news report. A character doesn't lose whatever makes sense about them in that setting just because you're sitting outside the television holding something from a game. I like that somebody had to think through that distinction. The easy version would be giving you one predictable outcome no matter what you aimed it at. This one makes what you're watching a part of how the effect behaves.
The recovery story goes in a nastier direction. The previous owner thought he'd changed real events based on what he kept seeing in his altered news coverage. Things in that version of the news got worse, even though the world outside his house had not changed the way he thought. It's easy to see the mistake from where I'm sitting with the whole file in front of me. He gets more and more footage that seems to back him up. That's what makes his story work for me, even before it gets to the stuff it can't explain cleanly. There's also a later fragmentary test log that makes me less willing to assume the viewer has the only say in how the scene goes. The missing bits make it hard to say when the viewer stopped being in charge.
I think the scene I'd write would be a watch party, well after anything happened with the Zapper. Let one person be the only one who knows why the recap doesn't match what everyone else remembers. They have to decide whether to explain themselves now or wait and see how far the difference goes. And if the other people start laughing at something that isn't funny on their screen, I think I'd just stay with that face a little longer than feels comfortable. They aren't trying to change the show anymore. They'd probably give just about anything to be able to watch one episode without having to ask which version of it they got.
SCP-674
· SCP