SCP-662
Mr. Deeds can do your dishes and apparently do a better job of it than the people who usually wash them. Ask him to cut your hair and things don't go quite as well. I appreciate both of those results being in the same file. The idea of ringing for an impossible butler would be less fun if every job he took turned out perfectly. I'd like to know which researcher looked at all the things they could ask this man to do and decided they were comfortable taking the chance on a haircut.
It starts with a small silver handbell that has lost the piece inside that would normally make it ring. Shake it anyway and you hear a chime from somewhere. Mr. Deeds walks up from the nearest place nobody can see, knows how to address the person holding the bell, and asks what they want. He's polite about the requests he can't fulfill. He's also polite about the things he can, and that gets stranger the further into the list you go.
I like the decision to make him come around a corner instead of appearing in a puff of smoke. A doorway you can't see through is a real part of any room, and if you know he's about to show up, you'll look for the spot he'd be most likely to come from. Then you've got the problem of watching it. Look directly at that spot and it doesn't meet the condition anymore. This is the kind of rule I like in a ghost story, too. It leaves me doing one extra little bit of work while I read, thinking about the rooms I know and all the places I couldn't check at once.
The results have enough variation that there's a reason to read the list instead of skipping to the acquisition report. He can get a sandwich or a piece of gold, but the gold doesn't come out at the purity somebody asked for. A particular car is beyond what he can provide. He's able to wash the car somebody already owns, which I find funnier than I probably should. If you're inventing rules for a character like this, small distinctions will carry you further than a chart that tries to define the exact limit in advance. The file lets somebody make a very particular request and lets him come back with a very particular apology.
Then there are the requests that leave you feeling differently about how obliging he is. The article doesn't make the switch with a grand change in his demeanor. He has the same manner whether somebody is putting a household chore on him or expecting him to hurt someone. He's also been hurt and killed himself in tests, and the next time he comes back after being out of sight, the damage is gone. I don't think the absence of a lasting injury gives you a good answer to what it was like for him while it was happening. The people running the tests seem a lot more interested in when the injury disappears than in what that might mean.
I can see why this is one people remember. You can explain it in a sentence and then spend an hour picking at all the decisions hidden in that sentence. I probably would ask him for something small first. I can also see how fast I'd get used to not having to know where it came from or what he did while he was gone. That's the part of the bell I'd be interested in writing about. The first favor gets an explanation and a thank you. A couple of weeks later somebody rings it without even getting up, and by that point they may have stopped thinking about whose afternoon they just interrupted.
SCP-662
· SCP