SCP-661
The food processor is my favorite example in SCP-661. Somebody listens to an ad for one and suddenly thinks it would make a nice gift for his mother. That sounds like a real reason to buy a food processor. It also sounds like the kind of reason you'd give if someone asked why you were looking at a product you'd never cared about before and you had to come up with an answer. I don't think I'd trust myself to tell those two apart.
SCP-661 is a former advertising voice who can make people want what he tells them to want. The person has to understand him. From the way the article describes it, the effect is generally mild and can stick around in the back of someone's mind for days. If a chance to get the thing comes up, it feels natural to take it. The recordings are a concern as well, which makes the advertising background more than a cute choice of former job. He didn't need to be in the room with every person who heard the commercial.
I wouldn't want him to be able to make anybody do anything. That'd be a lot simpler to write around, but I wouldn't be thinking about it after I put my phone down. The article tests him against people who have a much more immediate reason to do something else. It also puts him in front of a person who doesn't understand English. All he can do in that situation is try to talk to somebody who can't make sense of the words. Seeing him fail did more to make him feel like a person than hearing him ask for a lawyer did, and I already thought asking for a lawyer was fair.
I had a harder time deciding how to feel about the people keeping him there. I understand why they don't want him walking out and talking to whoever he wants. I also read a list of mundane requests that some staff turn into little opportunities to mess with him. Some of the jokes in that list are funny from a distance. For me they got less funny the longer I thought about what it would be like to need the approval of those same people for anything that made the room more bearable. One member of staff eventually calls them out for it. I'm glad the article didn't let that sit there as if everybody in the building agreed it was harmless.
I'd use an ability like this in a story by giving the person under its influence something else to do first. Let them finish a conversation, get on with the day, and remember halfway through another task that there's something they could pick up while they're out. The urge ought to fit into the day without changing the shape of it. If the story gives you a big warning every time his voice does anything, you get a nice clear line between the person's actual decision and the one they were nudged into. I prefer this thing when I can't see the line.
I still come back to the guy and the food processor. Giving him a mother who might use it is enough to make an out-of-character purchase sound thoughtful. It would have been easy to make him ask to buy twenty of them on the spot and move on to the next test. A single purchase that he can explain is much worse. Even if I knew exactly where that thought came from, I don't know if I'd throw out the idea afterward. What if it actually was a good gift? The article got me arguing for keeping a decision I hadn't made in the first place, and that's pretty damn close to the effect it's describing.
SCP-661
· SCP