SCP-657
I don’t think I’d ask Gustav when I was going to die. What I’m less sure about is whether I’d believe myself after sitting across from him for an hour. I can say I wouldn’t want to know when it’s hypothetical. Put a man in front of me who might actually be able to tell me and I think I’d have to start over on what that answer means.
The man in SCP-657 goes by Gustav or Mr. Nobel. He can predict when a person will die after physical contact, and that can be as ordinary as shaking his hand. When it’s close he can be very precise. When it’s a long way off he may only have a year. He says he doesn’t get the cause or the circumstances. That's the cruelest part of the ability to me. If he says I have a week, a week doesn’t tell me what to change. It tells me I can start looking for a threat in everything I see, all day, for as much of that week as I get.
His work as an undertaker is an easy fit but the article doesn’t leave him in an office waiting for the main character to knock. He gets angry with a coworker and makes a prediction other people hear. The coworker dies. Later he predicts the death of one of the officers taking him into custody, and that officer is killed in an unrelated incident. The police have every reason to investigate what he knows. What bothers me is the Foundation arranging a conviction and a death sentence to get its hands on him. Knowing a time is not evidence he caused either death. The institution gets the body it needs to study while the public gets a very different explanation for why the man is gone.
That’s why the really interesting classification here is Safe. If you read the article with safety as a question about what’s going to happen to Gustav, the label starts feeling almost sarcastic. He’s physically comfortable in a furnished room. He even gets more leeway to ask for entertainment after his freedom of movement is taken away. They can provide him with decent treatment in one sense while doing something profoundly unsettling in another. I like that the file takes both things seriously enough to write them down, but never stops to reconcile them for you.
There’s also the question of what happens when his ability fails. He reports it doesn’t work on a handful of people, without an established explanation. Then they arrange for him to touch SCP-076-2 under a false pretense. He passes out and is comatose for more than a week. When he recovers he says he doesn’t remember the meeting. I’m glad that neither the blackout nor the failure gets handed to us as proof of immortality or any one clean answer. It’s evidence that these researchers don’t know what contact does in every circumstance. You can see how that’s a much bigger deal to the guy making contact than it is to the people taking notes.
As a writing idea, I’d want to stay with the question of when a prediction becomes somebody else’s responsibility. Is Gustav obliged to tell anyone? Is he allowed to decide who hears it? Would any of us want a friend to have it and keep it secret? I don’t think there’s a single answer that’s good for the person giving the prediction and the person receiving it. That’s what I’m still thinking about after the file. The date could be completely accurate, and there still wouldn’t be any simple way to live with it.
SCP-657
· SCP