SCP-652
A Basset Hound that delivers the weather in a bunch of languages sounds like a pretty good setup for a ridiculous SCP. I was picturing somebody trying to get a local forecast out of him and getting news about a storm half a world away. That version of the story lasted about as long as it took me to get to his history.
The dog speaks in place of barking. His predictions are accurate when the people studying them can identify the locations, but there’s no clear sign he gets to decide when to talk or what to say. Even when he sleeps, it comes out as a mumble. That got to me more than the accuracy did. I like the idea of a talking dog. I wouldn't like the idea of my dog never getting any quiet.
The Foundation finds evidence that he's been mistreated. Then you read a partial business letter from Marshall, Carter and Dark, and whoever’s writing it is concerned with a dissatisfied customer and their policy on refunds. The dog barely registers as a living thing in that conversation. I didn't need to read the rest of the letter to get what kind of people had been handling him.
What I'd have liked to see is a quiet little follow-up about somebody learning what he enjoys. Would he still perk up to go outside if he woke up in the middle of another weather report? Would somebody learn to listen for the difference between the voice and a normal sign that he wants attention? I don't need an answer to how he can talk nearly as much as I'd like to know whether he's having a better day.
I can see why the forecast would be the first thing the researchers pay attention to. It's something they can record, sort and check afterward. If I only saw the entries in a notebook, I could spend all afternoon wondering where the places were and how often he got it right. The file put me back in the room with the dog. Once I was thinking about what it's like for him to live with that voice, the numbers felt like a much smaller part of what was going on.
I kept trying to picture a person who doesn't know anything about the forecasts meeting him for the first time. They wouldn't hear an interesting data point. They'd hear a dog making a sound dogs do not make. Once they got past the initial shock, they'd still have to figure out whether he wanted to play, eat or be left alone. That introduces a strange problem. Normally I can tell a lot about a dog by what it does with its voice. With him I'd have to get over how distracting the words were and pay more attention to the rest of him.
The business letter bothered me because it sounds like an exchange that could have been about almost anything. The customer isn't happy, and somebody wants to put a limit on what the company owes them. You don't have to imagine a huge speech from the people selling him. You learn how they think by what they consider worth talking about. I wonder how long somebody has to do that kind of business before they can write a letter like that without even thinking about the animal on the other end of the deal.
If I wrote the next scene, I wouldn't try to make him give some perfectly timed forecast that meant he appreciated being rescued. I'd rather see a person sit nearby long enough to learn where he likes to lie down. It could take a while for him to get used to having somebody there. I'd be fine reading a whole scene where getting a little closer is all that happens.
I appreciate that the containment instructions include things he’s afraid of. Those details tell me he still reacts to his surroundings like a dog, regardless of what comes out of his mouth. Of all the questions the Foundation could ask, whether somebody can make him comfortable seems like one they might actually be able to answer.
SCP-652
· SCP