SCP-651
SCP-651 hits a particular nerve for me because the horror is about losing ordinary abilities in pieces. It's a fictional illness that causes parts of the body to fuse together. That premise is plenty gross on its own, but the case notes give you something sadder to think about than what it looks like.
One person lives for years with the condition and spends a long stretch of that time unable to communicate. I kept coming back to that part. What does everybody in the room assume about you when you can no longer correct them? How often do they even think to ask a question if they aren’t sure they can get an answer? I can imagine silence doing as much to isolate somebody as the walls of the medical ward.
The file’s blunt about what prolonged survival costs. That's easy to get wrong in a horror story. If you run straight to the worst image you can come up with, the reader doesn't have much time to care about the person it’s happening to. Giving even a little sense of the time that passes made me dwell on it more.
There’s a difference for me between giving a reader the name of a condition and giving them a reason to remember the person with it. The file doesn’t have a lot of room for the second thing, which makes me want to look for it in what isn’t said. I kept thinking about the conversations happening around the patient and how easy it would be to talk over them without realizing that’s what you’re doing.
What I find hard about the prolonged case is that the person can spend an awful lot of time surrounded by people who have very short things to do. Somebody comes in, does a check and leaves. They might do their job well, but nobody else has to spend the whole day in that room. Even if the routine is reassuring to the staff, I don't know that it would be reassuring to the person who can't ask what any of it means. That's the part that makes a couple of lines about passing years land for me in a way a longer description of the physical effects wouldn't.
I also kept thinking about how much our picture of a person depends on little corrections. If I mention that somebody likes a particular song, they can tell me they got sick of it years ago. If I tell a story wrong, they can butt in and get it right. Those are tiny things, and I probably wouldn't think to miss them until I couldn't do them. It would be very easy for people to build a picture of who I'm supposed to be, and I'd have to sit there while it got further and further away from me.
The point of view would be the hardest thing to get right if I wrote something off this premise. The report can tell me what a clinician saw. It can't tell me everything the person experienced, and that gap is the reason I don't want to decide for them when they felt afraid or gave up hope. I could get more mileage from someone trying to make the best of an ordinary visit and not knowing if they're helping. I'd let them get some of it wrong, too. Someone could care a lot about the person and still be impatient because they want an answer the person can't give.
A detail like somebody leaving a radio on might bother me the next day more than the scene that made me wince. It would depend on whether I knew the person in the bed wanted it on, and how long it had been since anybody thought to ask.
If I were writing a scene set around this, I'd want to know what the patient would most want somebody to understand. Nothing huge necessarily. It could be about the noise in the room or who comes to visit on a particular day. Those are the things that make it feel like there’s still a life going on in that room, no matter how little of it ends up in the file.
SCP-651
· SCP