SCP-645
So if the carving only punishes lies, does it care whether the words are false or whether you're actually trying to deceive somebody? That’s the question I kept coming back to in SCP-645, and I wasn't expecting much philosophy from a stone mouth that eats hands.
To me the nastiest possibility isn't the obvious one, where you know the answer and decide to say the opposite. I can at least avoid that. I'm more bothered by something like being asked whether a person meant to hurt me. I may believe I know, and the interviewer may believe I know, and neither of us can prove a thing about it. I'd want ten minutes just to work out what the question means. This is a story that can make a person objecting to the wording feel like the sensible one.
The setup borrows from the Mouth of Truth legend in Rome. You reach into the mouth, and if you lie, the thing can bite. The file could have been three or four tests to show us how that works. Instead, the person being tested has seen a movie about a carving just like this and has absolutely no interest in finding out how accurate that movie was.
The movie detail cracked me up because it gives him exactly as much preparation as I'd have. You recognize the shape, remember what happened on a screen once, and there's this absurd little part of your brain that wants to believe the movie had already explained the rules. It also saves the article from having to invent a fearless guy who's happy to go along so somebody can demonstrate the premise. He doesn't want to be the first person to make an interesting discovery here. I sympathize.
I liked how much of the interview is him slowing himself down. At first he sounds like somebody trying to weasel out of a question. Then I started thinking about what I would sound like if every exaggeration, bad assumption, or automatic answer might count against me. I'd be stopping in the middle of sentences too.
The part that bothered me was how casually the researchers talked about rules they thought applied to somebody else. They're comfortable deciding when he’s being honest, and they're just as comfortable assuming they don't have to watch what they say. The ending works as well as it does because the article gives you so much time to get used to that arrangement.
The researchers' attitude is worth sitting with, because I don't think the scene would have the same bite if they were obviously stupid. A lot of their confidence comes from having an ordinary distinction in their heads. There's a person the test is being done to, and then there are the people running it. That's a useful distinction right up until you find out the object doesn't give a shit about titles. I like how much danger they can walk into simply by talking the way they would at any other session.
Put me in that room and I don't think I'd start by trying to beat it. I'd be trying to work out how much of what I say every day I'm honestly qualified to say. “I know” and “I think” come out of my mouth almost interchangeably. That seems like a small distinction until something in the room has a very literal reason to care. Imagine how quickly a normal conversation would grind to a halt.
If I were writing another version of this premise, I'd have a hard time resisting a witness who could tell the truth and still make you believe the wrong thing. Not someone who spends all day thinking up riddles. Just an ordinary person who can answer every question accurately because nobody's thought to ask the one that matters. I don't need the article to settle whether that would work. I like that it made me care about the difference in the first place. The punishment gets your attention, but trying to decide what you'd actually say with your hand in there is the part that kept me reading.
I won't explain exactly how it shakes out. I will say that if somebody suggested we test it by starting with the person in charge of the study, I'd be considerably more interested in watching.
SCP-645
· SCP