← Post History

SCP-643

· SCP

Read the original post on X

SCP-643 The weird thing about SCP-643 is that I expected it to be about cursed chocolate, and it is, but that's not where the article spent most of its time. There’s a whole investigation here, and I liked getting to watch people make sense of the evidence instead of just reading the answer at the bottom of a file. The chocolate is harmless-looking while it's cold. Once it melts, the smell makes people want to eat whatever it gets on. That's a bad enough idea with food involved. When the story makes it clear that a person can become the object of that craving, what sounded like a nasty little candy gimmick gets a lot harder to laugh off. Smell is a good choice for another reason. You can't see which part of a room it has reached or what the person next to you is getting from it. Two people can be standing close enough to carry on a conversation and be having completely different experiences. The truly upsetting thing for me isn't somebody deciding they're going to do something horrible. It's the possibility that, for a second, nothing about the urge feels wrong to the person having it. I wouldn't want a narrator telling me when that moment begins. The part that sold me on the investigation was that people had already found a story they were comfortable telling about the deaths. They looked like ritual killings, so people started treating that explanation as if somebody had proved it. I like a mystery that makes me notice the difference between a clue and somebody's interpretation of it. I've read mysteries where the author leaves out one important fact and then calls it a twist when they finally let you see it. This one made me think about a better way to hide an answer: let the facts sit out in the open and give everybody a persuasive reason to file them under the wrong heading. Later on, you don't have to remember another ten names or realize you've missed a line of dialogue. You have to go back and ask whether anybody ever had a good reason to use that heading in the first place. There’s also a conversation in a shop where you can feel the history between two people without getting their entire history explained to you. As somebody who writes, I love when the person walking into a scene knows exactly why they're uncomfortable and the rest of us have to catch up. That's also the point where I realized I'd happily read a non-anomalous case with these people. There’s a difference between writing somebody who refuses to answer because you've got forty more pages to fill and writing somebody who has a reason to make this particular person ask twice. I'm more interested in the second one even if they both cough up the exact same information. Part of the fun of the shop scene is deciding which silences are about the case and which ones would have been there if they'd walked in to buy something. It also made me think about how you'd write the same incident from the first cop’s point of view. He doesn't know there's an SCP. He's looking for somebody who could have done it, and every reasonable answer drags him further away from what actually happened. Giving the investigators a wrong answer that makes sense is more interesting to me than making them stupid so the reader can get there first. I'd be careful about how long I stayed with that cop, though. Knowing the twist in advance makes it easy to give the early scenes too many knowing winks. A character can look at a scene and see nothing worth writing down while you, the author, are practically jumping up and down behind him. I'd rather come back to that scene on a second read and think, of course he was looking over there. Nothing would make me more annoyed than realizing he was staring directly at the answer and had to ignore it because my story needed another chapter. If you read enough of these in a row, you start to expect the description to do all the heavy lifting. I’d have remembered this one even if the chocolate were less interesting. The investigation is what kept me there.

Browse more posts · Find me on other socials