SCP-493: YOU DON'T HAVE TO AGREE WITH YOURSELF
Imagine dying, coming back as two younger versions of yourself, and eventually discovering that you can't stand the other one's opinions.
SCP-493 begins with a man whose deaths produce two new adults, each carrying the memories of that branch's previous lives. Afterward they can live independently, without a shared mental connection. Their common origin goes back to a Swiss Protestant pastor, but centuries of separate experience produce individuals with their own circumstances and disagreements.
The Foundation discovers the phenomenon when one of its researchers dies. Some later instances continue working there. Others are contained, and the organization worries about the population increasing with each death. Two working instances eventually use the rule against overseeing contained family members to get reassigned away from a version they argue with.
That bit made me laugh because it feels entirely believable. Give people an extraordinary metaphysical problem and eventually somebody will solve their immediate inconvenience by finding the right paragraph in the employee handbook.
The larger question is what makes each person distinct. Identical beginnings don't guarantee identical conclusions. Put two versions of someone through different friendships, losses, jobs, and relationships, and I would expect them to change. It might be harder to accept those changes in someone who remembers being you than in an ordinary stranger.
You could spend an argument thinking that they ought to understand because they have your memories. Meanwhile, they are thinking exactly the same thing about you. Shared experience can provide common ground without settling what either person thinks that experience meant.
The immortality is less comforting than it first appears, too. Memories survive, but the body that dies still dies. Whether either successor feels like a continuation wouldn't automatically answer every question about the person who went through that final experience. I would want a lot more than the phrase "you'll come back" before accepting a dangerous assignment.
There is also a practical cruelty in treating every new instance mainly as a multiplication problem. I understand why the Foundation would calculate the numbers. I would still hate to be a person whose arrival was greeted primarily as additional paperwork and a threat to future storage capacity.
The article leaves plenty of room for humor, but the individual lives are what make the idea worth thinking about. One version can prosper while another becomes isolated. Their shared origin doesn't distribute comfort or good fortune equally.
If I met another version of myself, I would probably start with curiosity. After a few political arguments, I might understand why those researchers became so enthusiastic about reassignment.
https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/scp-493
SCP-493: YOU DON'T HAVE TO AGREE WITH YOURSELF
· SCP