Here's my current Cloak and Dagger reading order, from their earliest appearances through the more recent material. It's not perfect, and I may still be missing some appearances. I organized it as best I could, and I'll keep adding to it as I catch up.
EARLY YEARS AND LEGACY
• The Spectacular Spider-Man #64, #69–70, #81–82, #94–96 and Annual #9
• Cloak and Dagger (1983) #1–4
• Cloak and Dagger (1985) #1–11
• Doctor Strange #78
• Marvel Age Annual #1
• Marvel Fanfare #19
• Strange Tales (1987) #1–19
• The Mutant Misadventures of Cloak and Dagger #1–19
• Marvel Graphic Novel #35: Predator and Prey
• Marvel Graphic Novel #56: Shelter from the Storm
• New Warriors #32–35, #48–51 and Annual #3
• Strange Tales: Dark Corners
• Marvel Knights #1–15
• Marvel Knights: Double Shot #3
EARLY EXTRAS
• Dark Reign: Mister Negative #3 (later origin flashback)
• Marvel Team-Up Annual #6
• New Mutants #23–25
• Power Pack #6–8
• Secret Wars II #9
• Power Pack #19 and #24–26
• Marvel Comics Presents #9
• X-Factor Annual #4
• West Coast Avengers Annual #4
• Thor Annual #14
• Fantastic Four Annual #22
• Web of Spider-Man #77–78
• Marvel Super-Heroes Summer Special #6
• Infinity Gauntlet #2–3
• Silver Surfer #52
• Infinity Gauntlet #4 and #6
• Marvel Super-Heroes Fall Special #7
POST-1992 AND BEFORE RUNAWAYS
• Amazing Spider-Man Annual #26
• Spectacular Spider-Man Annual #12
• Web of Spider-Man Annual #8
• Marvel Comics Presents #115, #119–122 and #133
• Maximum Carnage appearances: Web of Spider-Man #101, Amazing Spider-Man #378, Spider-Man #35, Spectacular Spider-Man #201, Web of Spider-Man #102, Amazing Spider-Man #379, Spider-Man #36, Spectacular Spider-Man #202, Web of Spider-Man #103, Amazing Spider-Man #380, Spider-Man #37 and Spectacular Spider-Man #203
• Carnage: Black, White & Blood #1 (later retrospective)
• Web of Spider-Man Annual #9
• Amazing Spider-Man Annual #28
• Nova (1994) #7
• Morbius: The Living Vampire #29
• Secret Defenders #22–25
• Code of Honor #2–3 (retrospective)
• New Warriors (1999) #1
• Black Widow: Deadly Origin #4 (later retrospective)
• Thunderbolts #57
RUNAWAYS AND HOUSE OF M
• Runaways (2003) #11–12
• House of M #3–6 and Captain America (2005) #10 (alternate reality)
• Runaways (2005) #9–12
CIVIL WAR THROUGH DARK REIGN
• Marvel Knights 4 #25
• Wolverine (2003) #42
• Civil War #2
• Black Panther (2005) #18
• New Avengers #23
• Civil War: X-Men #2
• Civil War #3
• Fantastic Four #539
• Amazing Spider-Man #534
• Civil War: Choosing Sides #1
• Civil War #4 and #6–7
• Black Panther #25
• Secret Invasion #1
• Fantastic Four #562
• Dark X-Men: The Beginning #1–2
• Uncanny X-Men #513
• Dark Avengers #7
• Uncanny X-Men #514
• Dark Avengers #8
• Dark Avengers/Uncanny X-Men: Exodus #1
• Deadpool (2008) #16
• Wolverine: Origins #42–45
• X-Men vs. Agents of Atlas #1–2
• Cloak and Dagger (2010) one-shot
• Wolverine: Origins #47
• Dark Wolverine #86
• Wolverine: Origins #48
SPIDER-ISLAND AND AFTER
• Wolverine #310, #312–313
• Fear Itself: The Deep #4
• Amazing Spider-Man #663 and #667
• Spider-Island: Deadly Foes #1
• Spider-Island: Deadly Hands of Kung Fu #1
• Amazing Spider-Man #668
• Spider-Island: Amazing Spider-Girl #2
• Spider-Island: Heroes for Hire #1
• Amazing Spider-Man #672
• Spider-Island: Cloak and Dagger #1–3 (overlaps with the event appearances above)
• Superior Spider-Man Team-Up #1
SHANGHAI AND SECRET EMPIRE
• Amazing Spider-Man (2015) #6–8 and Annual #1
• Secret Empire #0
• Secret Warriors (2017) #4 (overlapping flashback)
• Doctor Strange (2015) #23–24
• Secret Empire #2, #6 and #8
REUNION
• Cloak and Dagger: Shades of Gray #1–6. The three Digital Original issues collect the same six chapters.
• Cloak and Dagger: Negative Exposure #1–3
MORE RECENT APPEARANCES
• Amazing Spider-Man (2018) #10
• Doctor Strange (2018) #15–16
• Absolute Carnage: Lethal Protectors #1–3
• Absolute Carnage #5
• Venom (2018) #20
• Annihilation: Scourge Omega #1
• King in Black #1
• King in Black: Planet of the Symbiotes #1–3
• Savage Avengers (2022) #1–10
• Uncanny Spider-Man #2–5
• Luke Cage: Gang War #1–4
• Blood Hunters (2024, second series) #1–5
• Cloak or Dagger (2025) #1–2
Some of the early books above are grouped by series rather than interleaved issue by issue. I know there are more recent appearances still to add, and I'll update the order as I continue catching up.
Cloak and Dagger reading order
· Comics